Latka logo

Founder Interview

How Bootstrapped ProcessMaker Reached About 350 Mid-Market and Enterprise Customers (Interview with Co-Founder Brian Reale)

Interview Date
February 11, 2018
Interviewee
Brian RealeCo-Founder and CEO
Watch
Watch the full interview

Company Metrics at Interview Time

Customers (2018)

350

Subscription Growth (2018)

30% a year

Gross Churn (2018)

12% a year

Historical Snapshot

These numbers were reported by Brian Reale during the interview recorded in February 2018 and are a historical snapshot, not current figures. See ProcessMaker’s current numbers.

Key Takeaways

  • 01ProcessMaker had approximately 350 enterprise and mid-market customers as of early 2018
  • 02Average contract value ran $25,000 to $30,000 per year, excluding professional services
  • 03Subscription revenue grew around 30 to 35% per year as a fully bootstrapped company
  • 04Gross revenue churn was approximately 12% annually, with net churn approaching zero after upsells
  • 05CAC payback was targeted at 12 months or less, with most growth coming from organic SEO and word of mouth
  • 06The company removed roughly 15 early shareholders from the cap table using proceeds from a small asset sale
  • 07The team numbered approximately 130 to 140 employees worldwide, headquartered in Durham, North Carolina
  • 08Brian put customer lifetime at roughly four to five years, a calculation he said he tends to ignore when setting payback
  • 09Brian and his co-founder retained primary control of the cap table with only five total entities remaining

Company Metrics at Time of Interview

MetricValueSource
Customers (2018)350Founder interview, Feb 2018
Subscription Growth (2018)30% a yearFounder interview, Feb 2018
Avg Contract Value (2018)$25,000 to $30,000 a yearFounder interview, Feb 2018
Gross Churn (2018)12% a yearFounder interview, Feb 2018
Team Size (2018)130 to 140 employeesFounder interview, Feb 2018
Estimated Customer Lifetime (2018)4 to 5 yearsFounder interview, Feb 2018
Cap Table Entities (2018)5 totalFounder interview, Feb 2018
Shareholders Removed from Cap TableAbout 15Founder interview, Feb 2018
Year Founded2000Founder interview, Feb 2018

Growth Breakdown

Revenue

Brian did not give a revenue or ARR figure during the interview. When Nathan Latka estimated revenue from the customer count and contract size, Brian answered only "Approaching it," and said of the host's figures: "Numbers are a little bit different, but more or less there." The number he did give was growth: ProcessMaker grew its subscription business "around 30, 35% a year," bootstrapped.

Customers

At the time of the interview, ProcessMaker served approximately 350 enterprise and mid-market customers across banking, manufacturing, and higher education. Brian noted the company had shifted focus away from SMB toward mid-market and above, and was prioritizing expansion within the existing customer base.

Team

The team had grown to approximately 130 to 140 employees worldwide between the 2008 open source launch and the interview date. Brian said the business had grown "very much organically" since then, bootstrapped. Headquarters were in Durham, North Carolina.

Profitability and Funding

ProcessMaker was fully bootstrapped at the time of the interview, carrying no debt and maintaining tight control of the cap table. Brian and his co-founder had used proceeds from a small asset sale to buy out roughly 15 early shareholders, leaving only five total entities on the cap table.

Growth Strategy

Organic SEO and Word of Mouth

Brian credited most of ProcessMaker's growth to organic search engine optimization and word of mouth referrals. He said the company had not made "really sophisticated calculations" about marketing spend, and put its acquisition cost "quite a bit under" the first-year contract value Nathan Latka used as the worst case.

Open Source as a Growth Engine

After eight years under a different premise, the company launched ProcessMaker as an open source project in 2008, with one employee. Brian said "that's really when it took off."

Expansion Within Existing Customers

At the time of the interview, Brian said the company was taking a much closer look at its existing 350 customers and had identified significant untapped growth there. He said upsells had brought net churn toward zero, and the goal was to get it "clearly into negative territory."

Vertical Focus

Having moved away from SMB to "mid market and above," Brian said ProcessMaker was "looking at the verticals we're competitive in" and wanted "the kind of growth rate we wanna grow at" in "the verticals we've most recently identified." He did not name those verticals; the customer examples he gave came from banking, manufacturing and higher education.

Multiyear Upfront Deals

Brian said ProcessMaker did "some interesting upfront multiyear deals," getting "a few of those in any given year," which "can help balance out cash positions pretty well." Its standard subscriptions, on premise and SaaS alike, were annual and charged upfront.

Best Quotes

“So we we grow our subscription business around 30, 35% a year. So, you know, we take a relatively conservative approach since it's our money.”
“So churn, I think for us, sort of that top level churn without the upsells, it's about 12% annually. I think for this kind of enterprise space, that's pretty normal.”
“Most of our growth has been through organic growth, so word-of-mouth and inbound search engine optimization. So we haven't made really sophisticated calculations in terms of extensive spend on the marketing side, but we would look for it in the first year.”
“today we're debt free, and it also means I can sleep more easily at night and not have to really worry too much. That's after rough startup days, those memories are still present, and I tend to want to avoid that stress.”
“we had one sort of interesting event along the way, provided some liquidity, some cash for us, so we decided, hey, it's a good time to let those very early investors get out. And then it gives us... Gave us more flexibility going forward to sort of manage the business in a slightly different way.”
“I guess I wish that I had just established product market fit earlier, so I would look for that more quickly.”

What Happened Next

This interview captured ProcessMaker in February 2018 as a bootstrapped workflow automation company with around 350 mid-market and enterprise customers and subscription revenue growing at roughly 30% per year. Brian Reale described a business focused on deepening vertical penetration and pushing net churn, which upsells had brought toward zero, clearly into negative territory. The figures and plans discussed here reflect the company at that point in time and should be read as a historical snapshot. Visit the ProcessMaker company profile for the most current available information.

View ProcessMaker’s current profile and metrics

Run a software or AI company? Get interviewed by Nathan Latka and tell the story behind your numbers.

Full Transcript

Introduction and Company Overview

Nathan Latka

00:00Hello, everyone. My guest today is Brian Reale. He's a serial entrepreneur, and his current company is called processmaker.com. Before that, he founded and later sold a telecom... In the telecom space, a long distance voice and data carrier based out of South America. He graduated from Duke University in 1993 and was a Fulbright scholar in linguistics in Ecuador 1994. Brian, are you ready to take us to the top?

Brian Reale

00:22I am. Alright.

What ProcessMaker Does: Automating Request and Approval Processes

Nathan Latka

00:23Tell us about ProcessMaker. What's it do, and what's your business model? How do you make money?

Brian Reale

00:27Yeah. So ProcessMaker is is all about automating processes. So these tend to be request and approval processes. So basically, anything that involves a form that's pulling in data and is being routed for approval. So that's a bit of a mouthful. So to give you some examples, we're talking about credit requests, credit applications for banks, and we have a lot of banking customers. We're talking about purchase requests for a lot of manufacturing companies. We have a lot

00:55of manufacturing companies. And in higher ed, it could be something like a grade change request, a transfer request, a professor ascension process or request, or any kind of change management type requests.

Nathan Latka

01:09Okay, and mean, is this like plumbing that's going on behind the scenes? You're connecting APIs or?

Brian Reale

01:14Yeah, good question. So it can be more plumbing, but it also can be less plumbing. So a lot of times it is actually the interface itself, and then it's got some plumbing behind the scenes. So we're connecting APIs to bring in data mostly from systems like core systems, ERPs, CRMs, and then we're sort of routing that for humans to make approvals and generate changes in the information, which gets put back in through the plumbing back into

01:40the core systems, back into the ERPs or core system.

BPM vs Integration Platforms

Nathan Latka

01:42So so when I bring up off the top of my head some some folks that I think about when I... When you give me that description, I think of Segment, Workato, Elastic, Zapier, SnapLogic, Jitterbit kind of companies. What do you think when you hear those companies relative to what you do?

Brian Reale

01:57Kind of Jitterbits and Zapier's or SnapLogic, those would be a little more into a category called integration Platform as a Service. So we're in kind of business process management, or BPM, or workflow. So workflow and BPM has an element, an overlap with Integration Platform, so we do do integration, but a lot of times we'll see customers that already have an Integration Platform, is good news for us because then it makes it easier to get the data

02:22we want in and out. And we're gonna be much more of the kind of human powered forms that are getting routed around. So those kind of companies won't do very well with the approval and rejection part of a workflow.

Nathan Latka

02:36So the key element there is it's some human form they're filling out. It's a PDF they're printing and scanning back to an email for something, things like that.

Brian Reale

02:44Exactly. There's usually this idea of a validation. In Europe, they'll call it validations. We tend to look at it as approval. Approval reject decision moments. That's kinda where workflow comes in.

Business Model: SaaS vs On-Premise

Nathan Latka

02:56Got it. That makes good sense. Tell me about the model. Is it pure SaaS, or what's your revenue model?

Brian Reale

03:01So it's not pure SaaS. We do both on premise and SaaS. SaaS has been, as you can imagine, growing sort of faster in more recent years. The reason there's still a lot of on premise is because this is... Deals with a lot plumbing, as you mentioned, and it is very much mid market and enterprise. So there's a lot of legacy systems, a lot of legacy systems where we're being brought in because we have greater flexibility, better

03:24front ends, but there are enterprises which are still doing a lot of that on premise, so still want it still want it on premise. So we do both.

Nathan Latka

03:32And and is the on prem stuff, though, is it... In terms of how it hits your cash flow statements or or your balance sheets? I mean, this... It's still a predictable annual kind of event or no?

Brian Reale

03:41Yeah. For us, it's it's the same. It's still an annual subscription revenue. We charge upfront. Yeah. And they look and act the same way. From a support perspective, they're a little bit different.

Nathan Latka

03:52Interesting. Okay. And give me a general sense of the size of these bad boys. Are we talking $10 a year, a $100 a year, a million a year or more?

Average Contract Value and Pricing

Brian Reale

03:59So we're talking sort of $25,000 to $30,000 would be kinda average contract value for us, and and that doesn't include potentially professional services, which might be done by us or by, partners around the world. So this is kinda mid market and above, and it's tending... It's trending upwards for us as we go kinda further into mid market and enterprise type clients.

Nathan Latka

04:23Got it. And that's just to be clear, it's an annual $30,000 contract. Right?

Brian Reale

04:26Correct.

Company History and Bootstrapping Journey

Nathan Latka

04:27Yep, interesting. Let's get more of your backstory here. What year did you launch the company in?

Brian Reale

04:32So we launched ProcessMaker in 2008. The company was actually around for eight years previously, and we started under a totally different premise that didn't work out, and almost called it quits around 2002, 2003. But then kept going with some different types of projects we were working on, and in about 2008, discovered what we really wanted to do, which was workflow, and launched ProcessMaker as an open source project in 2008. We had one employee then, and that's

05:07really when it took off.

Nathan Latka

05:08And define "took off"?

Brian Reale

05:11Well, we are organically kind of grown and have grown the the business very much organically since then.

Nathan Latka

05:18Does that mean you're bootstrapped?

Brian Reale

05:20We're bootstrapped. Yeah. So today, we're about a 130, a 140 employees worldwide. So that happened between 2008 and today. So not exactly sort of overnight, but that's I think for for bootstrapping that's...

Nathan Latka

05:35It's never overnight, Brian. We... You and I know that it's never overnight.

Brian Reale

05:38Never overnight.

Nathan Latka

05:39Alright. And where's headquarters? Is it Durham?

Brian Reale

05:41It's Durham, North Carolina. Yes.

Nathan Latka

05:43Yep. Yep. Very interesting. Okay. So walk me through... I wanna understand. You said it in 2000... Like, early two thousand eight, quote, didn't work out. What what wasn't working out, and how did you have the intuition to know you gotta change something?

Brian Reale

05:55So we we started business in 2000. We set it up to do a reverse tradings auction site for directors and officers liability insurance.

Nathan Latka

06:05Okay. That'll put me to sleep, so I know I didn't work. No. I'm just kidding.

Brian Reale

06:08So that turned out to be right at the back end of the dotcom crash, and so it was very difficult to raise money. We sort of needed to raise money to do that. So we just, at that point, had a few developers on staff. We ended up taking on some random projects, and we were basically doing websites and database systems. And then eventually got a customer and sort of reflected upon what we were doing, and it

06:32looked and felt like workflow. So we started calling it workflow.

Nathan Latka

06:36Interesting. So to survive there in the middle, you took on some custom lower margin but higher contract, cash in the bank quickly things to sustain yourself.

Brian Reale

06:47Yeah. My other co founder went back to his day job. I had a day job, so we were basically doing whatever we could to just sort of keep the doors open for a period there.

Customer Count and Growth Rate

Nathan Latka

06:58And you made it through that that that down point, I guess we'll call it. What do have today in terms of total customers you're serving?

Brian Reale

07:05So today, around three fifty customers, really around the world, enterprise mid market customers.

Nathan Latka

07:14And generally growing at what rate would you say?

Brian Reale

07:18So we we grow our subscription business around 30, 35% a year. So, you know, we take a relatively conservative approach since it's our money and we

07:28wanna

Nathan Latka

07:28And you're

Brian Reale

07:28make

Nathan Latka

07:28bootstrap too.

07:29That's healthy growth for bootstrap company.

Cleaning the Cap Table

Brian Reale

07:32Yeah.

Nathan Latka

07:32In full control of the cap table?

Brian Reale

07:34Yes.

Nathan Latka

07:35You and your founder, co founder?

Brian Reale

07:37Yeah, yeah. In fact, a couple years back, we kinda helped. We cleaned it up a bit with a couple good years we had, just realizing that when bootstrapping, it really helps to have that control, as you kinda mentioned.

Nathan Latka

07:50Why was it... Why... This is a really important lesson here because a lot of entrepreneurs when I dig, they do some form of cap table cleaning, especially if it's a company that's been around for a while with a bunch of pivots. Why was it quote dirty in the first place? In other words, how did people get on it in the first place? Was it friends and family and angel around or early employees? And how did you

08:06negotiate to kind of quote clean it up?

Brian Reale

08:09Yeah. Good question. So as I mentioned, since we started off with a very much a different business plan, we initially took on some friends and family money. That was under the assumption of the previous business plan, which had to do purely with insurance and reinsurance specifically. They had been around for a long time, so that expectation of a momentous sort of exit right around the corner didn't happen for them, so we wanted to provide them a

08:39way out. And we had one sort of interesting event along the way, provided some liquidity, some cash for us, so we decided, hey, it's a good time to let those very early investors get out. And then it gives us... Gave us more flexibility going forward to sort of manage the business in a slightly different way.

Nathan Latka

08:57And what was the fortunate event?

Brian Reale

09:00We ended up having a small M and A transaction where we sold off an asset we had created that's still under confidentiality, but we ended up building the workflow that's deeply embedded in a leading enterprise system. Ended up kind of learning our lesson because the code slowly got forked. We realized it was going be better to try and sell that off, so we did. Then we took that cash and we were able to clean it up

09:28and pay a bit of a dividend.

Nathan Latka

09:30Interesting. I won't ask obviously the amount because you said you're still confidential, but generally speaking, how many individual entities were you able to remove from the cap table as a result of that deal?

Brian Reale

09:41Yeah, like 15.

Nathan Latka

09:42Oh, wow.

Brian Reale

09:43Yeah, so there were small, small shareholders who, again, they had been on for a long time. They were all happy to kind of move on and and and get money out. So...

Nathan Latka

09:55And give us a sense of kind of where you're at. I mean, we're talking like four or five entities on the cap table between you and your co founder plus maybe three or four others or?

Brian Reale

10:02Really three and then a... Yeah. Well, three and then a few... Five in total.

Nathan Latka

10:09Good. So significant cleaning. That's that's good stuff. Alright. Yeah. Now now in term term... In terms of growth rate real quick. So you mentioned 350 customers, $30,000 ACV. That means you guys are, what, somewhere around that beautiful $10,000,000 mark at this point. Is that about accurate?

Brian Reale

10:23Approaching it. Yeah.

Nathan Latka

10:24Yeah. Because you... I I saw you guys obviously on the Inc. 5000 in in 2015, growing a 130% year over year. I think you did five five that year, and 30% growth year over year since then will put you about ten five now.

Brian Reale

10:35Yeah. Yeah. A little a little bit... Numbers are a little bit different, but more or less there.

Nathan Latka

10:39It's harder to keep it's harder to keep growing a 133% year over year as the numbers get bigger, but but somewhere around 10,000,000 in terms of where you guys are at, totally bootstrapped is obviously a great spot to be. What are you focused on product wise moving forward? Are you focused at going and getting deeper and more wallet share from your current three fifty customers or going out and getting new customers with new offerings?

Brian Reale

10:58It's a good question. It's both, but we have taken a much closer look at our current customers and realized that there's a lot of growth there that we hadn't been realizing. So we're really focused on that this year. We've sort of become more honest with ourselves in terms of having landed clearly in mid market and above. We sort of entered the space thinking we were, I think, not really thinking at all, so we sort of entered

11:23the space looking at the kind of SMB or even smaller businesses, realized that doesn't really work for this genre of product. So we've now, we're kinda looking at the verticals we're competitive in, and also looking how we can offer more value to existing customers.

Nathan Latka

11:40Tell me about churn.

Churn and Net Revenue Retention

Brian Reale

11:43So churn, I think for us, sort of that top level churn without the upsells, it's about 12% annually. I think for this kind of enterprise space, that's pretty normal. It's not kind of clear clean SaaS where you just get the customers on and they tend to stay on. For us the challenge is actually getting the customer on, because it's a big decision. Customer has to be prepared to kind of put a team behind it, go forward

12:13to see the value, and sometimes there's shifts in management, shifts in the decision maker, so that's one of the challenges there. And then we're approaching that sort of of zero to negative percent churn with the upsells, but we think we can drive a lot more there.

Nathan Latka

12:29So gross revenue churn, call it 12%, you're about net zero right now, which means your expansion revenue from your current base grows about 12% year over year. That's why you're at zero, and you're working on getting that negative.

Brian Reale

12:41Correct.

CAC Payback and Unit Economics

Nathan Latka

12:42As a bootstrapped company, you can't afford to pay a lot upfront if it takes you one, two, three years to get the money back. What do you optimize payback period for?

Brian Reale

12:51We actually optimize it for that first year, meaning, you know, when we sell

12:59it, we'd like to see payback pretty immediately, so I would say even less than that. Most of our growth has been through organic growth, so word-of-mouth and inbound search engine optimization. So we haven't made really sophisticated calculations in terms of extensive spend on the marketing side, but we would look for it in the first year. So even though we recognize lifetime value is probably sort of four years, four and a half, five years, we just... I

13:28tend to ignore that calculation.

Nathan Latka

13:29It can lie to you very easily sometimes.

Brian Reale

13:32Yeah. And we'll also balance it. We do we do some interesting upfront multiyear deals. So we get... You get a few of those in any given year, and that can help balance out cash positions pretty well.

Nathan Latka

13:46So just to sum up those four unit economics real quick to make sure I've got them right. You like to optimize for a twelve month or less payback. It sounds like you're maybe even below that right now. If your first year ACV is about $30,000, it means you're acquiring these guys for less than $30,000 a pop, sometimes much, much lower than that. That's fully weighted. You have a team of hundred hundred and forty. I imagine some

14:04of them are sales. So it's fully weighted. You're direct paid plus any sales and marketing staff, and that puts your CAC again right around that that $30,000 mark at the worst case. Is that about right?

Brian Reale

14:13Yeah. At the very worst case. So, you know, we're we're we're looking quite a bit under that, in fact. So I've had people recently say, accuse me of sort of leaving too much growth on the table. Yeah. It's the term that's been thrown at me a lot lately, I think there is a trade off between leaving growth on the table and kinda mitigating risk. And when it's... When you're bootstrapping, I I think you tend to kinda

14:37lean towards mitigating risk because that could quickly throw your formula out of whack.

Fundraising and Future Plans

Nathan Latka

14:41Typically, the only kind of people throwing stuff like that at you would be investors who want you to take their money, control you, and then use their money to jack up your CAC. Are you raising capital right now?

Brian Reale

14:51We're not. And in fact, in this case, was a it was a marketer who obviously wants to spend more on marketing, and and that makes sense. So at least we are we are starting to get more aggressive there. And we... But, yeah, you're right. It's also sort of the the people that are looking to to place money.

Nathan Latka

15:06If someone came and offered you, especially this... Considering this is bootstrap and how clean your cap table is, if someone offered you call it 60 or $70,000,000 for the company, 6 or seven x ARR, would you sell?

Brian Reale

15:16We've sort of figured out that we need to go... We we need to... We've got a few years ahead of us just in terms of making sure... So one, we don't we don't think somebody would come today. We need to... We wanna line up a little more strongly in a few areas.

Nathan Latka

15:16What do you mean by that?

Brian Reale

15:16So sure, churn is under control today, we think we can do a little better, so we want to get

15:36it clearly into negative territory. We want to make sure that in the verticals we've most recently identified, we've got the kind of growth rate we wanna grow at, and then on the product side, we're making a couple interesting changes, we wanna have that story tightened down. So either to make sure that we can get an optimal investor, if we wanted to get an investor under optimal terms, So we're thinking that we've got at least two years

16:02before we even look at anything like that.

Venture Debt Consideration

Nathan Latka

16:04Interesting. To drive growth faster and do it in a non dilutive way, would you ever consider venture debt?

Brian Reale

16:10I've been hearing a lot more about debt options, and actually looked into one kind of recently. And I think if we identify

16:19the sort of lifetime value to CAC ratio exactly and feel totally comfortable with it, then we might consider doing something with debt. I mean, today we're debt free, and it also means I can sleep more easily at night and not have to really worry too much. That's after rough startup days, those memories are still present, and I tend to want to avoid that stress.

Famous Five Rapid Fire

Nathan Latka

16:41All right, Brian. Let's wrap up with the famous five. What's the last business book you read?

Brian Reale

16:47I'd say it's From Good to Great.

Nathan Latka

16:50Name your favorite CEO to have dinner with in Durham.

Brian Reale

16:55I guess it would be Marc, Marc Benioff.

Nathan Latka

16:57Is he in is he in... No. Name like a

16:59local He's gotta be in Durham.

17:00Name like a local entrepreneur you really respect.

Brian Reale

17:03Yeah.

17:04That's a tough one. Maybe maybe Joe who sold Bronto.

Nathan Latka

17:10Bronto. Yep. Yep. That was a good exit for that that area. Number three, what's your... Besides your own, what's your favorite online tool?

Brian Reale

17:17Favorite online tool? Jira.

Nathan Latka

17:19Jira.

17:20Number four. How many hours of sleep do get every night?

Brian Reale

17:23I'd say six and a half.

Nathan Latka

17:24That's pretty good. And what's your situation? Married, single, you have kids?

Brian Reale

17:27Married, three kids.

Nathan Latka

17:28Three... Are you empty nesting or no?

Brian Reale

17:31No. I'm pretty young.

Nathan Latka

17:32How how old are you?

Brian Reale

17:3447.

Nathan Latka

17:3447. Last question.

17:35Take us back to your twenty year old self, Brian. What do you wish you knew?

Brian Reale

17:40What I wish I knew when I was 20? That... Yeah. That it it can be a a... I guess I wish that I had just established product market fit earlier, so I would look for that more quickly.

Nathan Latka

17:54You're gonna be, like, in your college dorm and just be thinking, oh, I wish I had product market fit earlier, or this was... Or did you already have your first company at that age?

Brian Reale

18:02Shortly thereafter.

Nathan Latka

18:03Okay. Alright.

18:05Guys, there you have it from Brian. He's been through the fire. He's he's learned the lessons. He's now again building ProcessMaker. They launched it way back in 2000, went through some pivots, cleaned some stuff up in 2008, 2009 time frame. Now they're growing really health... Healthily. Did about 5,500,000 back in 2015. Now up near the 10 mark, serving about 350 mid market pushing enterprise size customers, paying about $30,000 per year in ACV, at least in year

18:29one. They are driving 12% expansion year over year, which more than washes out the 12% revenue churn. So they're right at about even there right now trying to get to that negative area quickly. They've got a 140 people with headquarters based in Durham. Again, unit economic super healthy. Brian, thank you for taking us to the top.

Brian Reale

18:45Thanks, Nathan. Appreciate it.